Main Dish | August 10, 2013

Tessa’s Mini-Melts with Poppyseed Drizzle

Tessa’s Mini Melts with Poppyseed Drizzle are the best type of party food! These little sliders are easy to make, are perfect for make-ahead and are so yummy. Just a few minutes of assembly and you’ve got a meal every guest will love!

Our oldest son Stephen left for his mission for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints to Puebla, Mexico on February 16, 2011. If you’ve been reading ABK for a while, you’ll remember this post. He returned two years, one month and three days later. It was a long time to be separated from our son!

The afternoon he returned, we dashed off to the airport with balloons and signs in hand. Our immediate and extended family gathered there, along with families of other missionaries who were returning that day. So much excitement. So much joy. So glad to have him home!

In honor of Stephen serving for two years we celebrated his return with (what else?) FOOD. We made lots of salads, treats and Tessa’s Mini-Melts with Poppyseed Drizzle. It was nice to have something warm to serve with the salads that didn’t require too much time in the kitchen! Especially when we wanted to enjoy time with our newly returned missionary.

My friend Tessa gave me this recipe after she made dinner for a large group of sorority girls at the University of Utah. She said the girls loved them, and I thought, if they’re good enough for the Chi-Omega’s they’re good enough for us!

These ham and cheese sliders take just a few minutes to put together, and are perfect for parties of any sort, from showers to
Grateful to have Stephen home.
So proud of his willingness to sacrifice and share the good word of God with the sweet people of Mexico.
Two years is a long time.
Yes, it is.



Mini-Melts with Poppy Seed Drizzle - for 20-100 people

Tessa Reinemer
Course Dinner
Cuisine American
Keyword ham and cheese, sandwiches, sliders


  • 3 dozen soft dinner rolls
  • 2 pounds deli meat or have the deli slice up the exact amount of slices you need*
  • 1 pound sliced deli cheese or approx 18 slices, cut in half


  • 2 tablespoons poppy seeds
  • 2 tablespoons yellow mustard
  • 1/2 cup butter
  • 1 tablespooon minced dehydrated onion optional
  • 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce


  1. Slice rolls and put small amount of turkey or ham with one slice of cheese. Place sandwiches in 2- 9x13 baking dishes or one large jelly roll pan.
  2. Heat ingredients for topping in a saucepan until butter is melted. Brush or spoon topping onto sandwiches right before cooking. Cover with foil. Bake at 350 degrees for 15 minutes or until cheese melts.
  3. Serves about 15-20.

Recipe Notes

(aka more than you ever wanted or needed to know about making baked sandwiches):
-These sandwiches may be assembled in advance. A day before is fine, but don't brush with drizzle until right before cooking. Store in fridge covered tightly with foil.
-*Deli meat- Slice the meat in half with a sharp knife (I cut the meat all at once). If you have 36 rolls, order 18 slices of deli meat, cut in half.
-We used a combo of ham/swiss and turkey/havarti. Both were delicious.
-For a gathering at the school, and Anibelle's baby blessing, I used Costco large croissants and cut them in half after stuffing with meat and cheese. We used:
3 doz large croissants
4 lbs ham or turkey
2 lbs sliced cheese
Served approx 75

  • I use the Walmart Brand rolls, found near their deli when making these for a large (100+) crowd. I pinned the rolls here, so you can see what they look like. The rolls come 16 to a package. I like these for a crowd, because they are inexpensive and they stack well, without smashing if you need to buy a large quantity.
  • I have also used a roll that looks similar to a Granny Sycamore cluster roll from Costco. They only sell these in the fall and winter months. This roll is much thicker than the Walmart brand roll, and I add more meat to the sandwich when using the Granny roll, so the meat is not lost in the roll!
  • Cooking for 100: plan on about 1 1/2 rolls per person if you are serving other buffet items such as salads, appetizers, sweets. 10 packages of "The Bakery" rolls from Walmart, (Potato or Sweet Hawaiian) 16 per pkg =160 rolls
  • Deli meat sliced, approx 80 slices, cut in half to yield 160 slices cheese slices, approx 80 slices, cut in half to yield 160 

1 1/4 lb butter, melted (5 sticks)
8 tablespoons poppy seeds
6 tablespoons mustard
3-4 tablespoons dehydrated onion (optional)
2 tablespoons Worcestershire
Follow directions above for baking.


14 thoughts on “Tessa’s Mini-Melts with Poppyseed Drizzle

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. sounds yummy! We make something very similar here in Alabama – we buy the package of rolls in the little metal pan (on the bread aisle) where the rolls are attached to each other. Slice the entire package of rolls in half and spread the butter/mustard/poppyseed mixture on the inside of the rolls and put the meat and cheese and wrap in foil and bake. Then slice around each little roll before serving. Your method sounds easier!! I might try it next time!

    1. Hi Lisa, I've heard of the rolls you use, my Sister in law used to live in Alabama. The Walmart Bakery rolls are really easy to use as well. Aren't these the best for parties? thx for the note 🙂 Have a great day!

  2. I've actually made these before, and they were called Hot Ham n' Swiss Sliders. Whatever you call them, the dressing really makes them.

    My son just left 10 days ago. And yeah, two years is so long that I'm trying not to think about it. :/

  3. These look delicious! A must try for our many large family gatherings.
    My youngest, barely 19 yr old daughter left 3 days for Paraguay, and tho its 18 months, it's a long time. I love all your recipes.

    1. Kathy, Paraguay! My Brother in law served there, and two of Stephen's best friends jsut returned from Paraguay. All three loved it there. Hope all goes well with her! Thanks so much, and have a great day 🙂

  4. Made these tonight. They were so good and even impressed my husband. Thats hard to do! I used honey ham/havarti on hawaiian rolls. Thanks for the crowd pleasing dinner idea.

    1. Ruth,
      These sandwiches just need to be warmed up and the cheese melted. An oven is the easiest way to do that (in my opinion) but if you don’t have access to an oven when you’re serving, I think a roaster would work. Let me know!

  5. These were so amazing for the Super Bowl this year! Because we weren’t making for a crowd we added peperoncini’s to ours it was so yummy. Then right before they were done cooking I switched to broil for a minute or two to crisp up the tops. It’s a yummy
    spin on a classic sandwich.