New in 2019 – ABK’s Free Thanksgiving Ebook, with printable timeline checklist, grocery list, more recipe links for ABK Thanksgiving favorites and additional Thanksgiving tips to help you keep everything running smoothly!
Follow the steps…
Pie crust is easy if you follow a few simple steps
-I suggest always gathering ingredients before you start. No one wants to make pie filling, heat up the oven and then find out they have zero flour in the house! Gather first, then bake.
-Use Crisco for baking, I like half regular flavor and half butter flavor (not butter, just Butter Flavor Crisco) for the flakiest crust ever. If you want your crust to taste like Grandma’s- use shortening!
-Follow the recipe directions exactly.
Practice time
Tools of the trade
Best Basic Flaky Pie Crust
Best Basic Flaky Pie Crust
Ingredients
- 2 cups flour all purpose
- 1 teaspoon salt I like sea salt
- 1 cup shortening less for single blind baked crust, see recipe notes**
- ½ cup very cold water more may be needed*
Instructions
-
Mix flour and salt.
-
Cut in shortening with pastry blender or knives using a cutting motion, no stirring, only a short cutting motion to form small pebble like pieces with flour, shortening and salt.
-
Add 1/2 cup water all at once.
-
Fold ingredients with fork until flour is absorbed and dough comes together. If needed, add more cold water, a tablespoon or two at a time, until the dough resembles something similar to biscuit dough. It should be damp, but not sticky. Do not add too much water.
-
Divide dough in half for two pie crusts. The dough should be soft and not sticky. If sticky, roll in a bit of flour.
-
Flour surface and rolling pin well. I use about 1/4 or more cups of flour on surface and spread in circle. Keep the rolling pin floured.
-
Flatten dough with hand to make round disc shape.
-
Roll out from center to about 1/8” thickness. Place the pie plate on top of the dough. The dough should be rolled out approximately 2 1/2 inches past the edge of the pie plate, to allow for the dough to sink into the corner of the pie plate, and also extend over the edge of the plate so an outer crust is easily formed.
-
Fold dough in half, lift onto pie plate.
-
Open and shape to pan, make sure to gently press the pastry into the corner of the pie plate.
-
Cut off excess dough if making a single pie crust. If making a pie to be baked with filling, fill the pie shell, top with crust if desired (if making apple or other fruit pies). Follow pie recipe directions.
If baking for single crust pie, follow directions below for Single Blind Baked Crust.
To bake a single crust:
-
Alter the recipe above to use 5-6 tablespoons of Crisco, instead of 8 tablespoons. This will help your crust to stay in place and not shrink! The crust will still be flaky and easy to handle, but your shrinkage will be less.
-
It is important when baking a single crust to form the edges of the pie to the very edge of the pie plate. Do not skimp on dough on the edge of the crust. You want to have a thick layer of crust in order to prevent shrinkage. I sometimes use about 3/4 of the crust recipe for a single pie crust if I want to make a crust with a pronounced edge.
-
Poke holes in the bottom and sides of the crust to prevent bubbles from forming in crust.
-
Turn oven to 500 degrees. Yes, 500! The oven should be very hot when you place the crust into the oven. Preheat for at least 15 minutes. (I like to preheat for 30 minutes).
-
Place the formed pie shell into your refrigerator (or better yet freezer) for 30 minutes, uncovered.
-
After the crust has been refrigerated or placed in freezer, bake for 7-10 minutes in preheated oven on CENTER rack. I bake on center rack for a single crust.
-
Keep an eye on your crust through the window in your oven( if you have one) after about the 5-6 minute mark. The crust is done in about 8 minutes in my oven if I am baking two single crusts at once. Baking time will vary depending on the oven. YOu may need a little more or less baking time.
-
Remove from oven and let cool completely after baking. This crust will stay fresh for 2 days on the countertop in a dry climate.
Recipe Notes
-Dough will be easier to handle if chilled for an hour or so if you are a beginner baker. Not necessary, but it may help in handling of dough.
-Try rolling the dough around the rolling pin and then unrolling right onto the plate.
-I always use ½ regular and ½ Butter Flavor Crisco. Note this is not butter, Butter Flavor Crisco.
-Some people like to “cut” the flour in with their fingers.
-Don’t cut the flour and shortening too much, the pieces of shortening are what make the crust flaky.
-If your pie is getting too brown on the edges, take a piece of foil, fold in half to make a square then cut a half circle out of the middle. Unfold and put over your pie.
-Brush beaten egg or egg white over your pie dough before filling with pumpkin to avoid soggy crust.
-Preheating the oven is essential when blind baking. The oven is ready for baking when the oven is heated to 500 degrees for over 15 minutes after reaching temperature.
-The amount of water will vary in they recipe depending on many factors: the brand of flour used, the type of shortening, the temperature of your kitchen, the bowl used for mixing, the water temperature and how you mix in the water after the shortening has been cut into the four. You may need additional water. Add a little at a time, making sure to never stir, use a folding motion when adding water.
-This recipe freezes well. You may roll out the dough onto pie plate and freeze immediately. Wrap with a piece of parchment paper on top of pie crust, then use Saran Wrap or slip pie plate into a large ziplock bag. When ready to use, do not thaw, just fill and bake or blind bake. You may also bake the pie crust, let cool completely and freeze. When ready to fill, let thaw and fill.
-You may freeze crust after wrapping into single crust portions. When I make a batch of dough, I split in half and make a disc shape, then wrap in Saran Wrap tightly. When ready to use, thaw in refrigerator or on counter top for about an hour. Roll out and bake as directed.
-I highly recommend glass Pyrex pans for baking, especially for beginner bakers. The glass makes it easy to see when the bottom crust is browned. The exception to this is if you are freezing a pie completely, and then baking. I highly recommend using a good quality metal pie plate when freezing pies.
){kind=link}
I do “love” near by…how did you know.
Your Republican comment made me burst out laughing….You are funny
ME
This is awesome. Thank you!
Thank you! Making this and your blueberry pie tomorrow!!
Do I need to double this recipe if the pie I’m making needs a top crust?
Do I put the pie crust in the oven at 500 while it’s warming up to 500, or after the oven has been heated to 500?
Alexandra, After the oven has been heated to 500. Sorry i missed this comment earlier!
I tried this and it worked pretty well. I made a quiche with it. My custard mixture leaked through to the bottom of the pie plate . . . any thoughts on how to prevent that?
Beth,
Make sure you don’t roll the pastry too thin. I haven’t had that issue with quiche! Also make sure there are no tears or holes in the crust before filling!
xo
Si
Another question about the temp of the oven, sorry! So once my oven reaches 500 do I leave it at 500 while the pie is baking? Or do I turn the oven off once it reaches 500 then put the pie in?
Brooke,
Yes leave it on to 500 while baking. Watch the pie carefully, it cooks quickly!
xo
Si
You picture looks like there’s is also butter in the recipe. Is there suppose to be?
I’m not Si, but I noticed in the notes that what you saw was 1/2 regular Crisco and 1/2 butter flavored Crisco.
Natalie,
You’re right! I find 1/2 regular and 1/2 butter flavored Crisco gives the crust a beautiful color as well as flavor.
Thanks for reading ABK!
xo,
Si
Do you cook pie crusts on a baking sheet or just on the rack side by side?
Allie,
Side by side in the oven with no baking sheet. I hope these directions are helpful!
xo,
Si
Hi Si,
I adore all of your pies! I’m anxious to make my first one for Thanksgiving. Your Apple pie recipe has me smitten! Would this work for your Apple pie recipe (with the big lattice crust top) xoxo
Steph,
Yes, This is my go-to recipe for pie crust. How did it turn out for you?
I hope your Thanksgiving was fantastic.
Thanks for reading ABK!
xo,
Si
Hey Kacie- I believe what you are seeing is the butter flavored Crisco – she used half regular flavor and half butter flavored Crisco.
Steph,
Yes, you’re right. I like the flavor and color of using 1/2 regular and 1/2 butter.
Thanks for your comment!
xo,
Si
Great pie crust, and I like using the half butter flavored and half regular Crisco. I’m using this recipe for your apple cranberry pie tomorrow!
Trisha,
I hope your apple cranberry pie was a hit this Thanksgiving!
Thanks!
xo,
Si
Your recipe says 1 cup shortening and you later reference 6-8 tablespoons depending on the pie you’re making. I’m confused because there are 16 T in one Crisco stick and one stick is one cup. So which is it? 1 cup or 6 T?
Jenny,
The recipe posted will make two crusts. I use 8 Tbsp (1/2 cup) each of butter flavored Crisco and regular Crisco for the recipe.
If you would like to make a single crust, the ingredients would be halved- except for the Crisco. I reduce the Crisco to 6 Tbsp and not 8 Tbsp.
I love how easy this crust is to work with. Give it a try!
XO,
Si
Can you make the crust ahead of time and freeze?
Rebecca,
yes, you can make ahead and either roll out into the pie plates and freeze or simply put the dough into disc shapes and wrap tightly and freeze. When ready to use, thaw and bake.
thanks for reading ABK!
xo
Si
Do you ever use a food processor for your crust? Does it overwork the dough too much?
Love your recipes!
Hi Alyson, I usually just make the dough by hand, I think the food processor would overwork it. Thanks for asking!
xo
Si
What are your thoughts on refrigerating the dough 24 hours in advance? Would that effect the crust at all?
Hi Emrey, you can refrigerate the dough 24 hours in advance. That won’t effect the crust at all. Thanks for asking!
xo
Si
I am no pro at making pie crust but all of your tips make it pretty darn easy! I love the texture and flavor that the crisco gives the crust!
She is the queen of pie crusts! Still need to practice to make mine look as beautiful as hers, but I don’t think anyone will complain having more pie around! Thanks for sharing your talent
This has become my go to pie crust recipe! Works well with butter when I run out of crisco.
I’ve been using the same Betty Crocker pie crust recipe since I was a teenager- until two Thanksgivings ago when I tried yours! I trusted it because I’ve loved every recipe I’ve tried from your site. This pie crust was just as flaky but way easier to work with, and held it’s shape much better, so it looked prettier. Another incredible ABK recipe for the books!
I was so nervous to make my first pie, but this made it incredibly easy. I even cheated a bit by using a food processor and it turned out great!
Sometime in the 80’s, one of the local Salt Lake stations did a segment on making pie crusts and this was the exact recipe they used. It was my go-to recipe ever after until they changed the formula on Crisco and the Butter flavor was too strong (I used all Butter flavor originally). Using half regular and half butter is genius. I can use this recipe again! Love your website. Very well done!
I agree Linda, using both is definitely the trick for a perfectly flaky crust. Thanks for sharing and for reading ABK!
xo
Si
Your tip to use 3/4 of the recipe for single crust converted my from a pie crust buyer to a ie crust maker….finally!!! Thank you!
You’re very welcome Chris! Thanks for sharing and for reading ABK,
Si
Si,
do you convection bake at 500* or conventional bake the pie crust?
Hi Katy, I set it too 500 degrees on regular bake. Thanks for asking!
xo
Si
I’m wondering about putting a glass pie plate that has been chilling in the fridge or freezer into a 500 degree oven…how do you avoid having the glass shatter/break?
Hi Dani, if you have a Pyrex pie plate or oven safe one, you shouldn’t have to worry about the glass breaking. Thanks for asking!
xo
Si
Thanks for the quick reply! I do have Pyrex, but always thought you couldn’t put any cold glass dish in a hot oven. Good to know!
Dani,
I want to clarify this. If you are freezing for a long period of time, you should use a metal pan instead of a glass pie plate. When I place a crust into the freezer to just firm up the crust, for 30-60 minutes, I don’t worry about the pie plate shattering. If you are freezing for a few hours, it is best to use a metal pan!
I know it will be a great pie crust because I use the same recipe w/o the salt & have been since 1972, when I was given this recipe when I was up in AK. So… here’s the deal, when I use a glass pie plate the crust slides down the sides BEFORE I can put in the filling… think of satin sliding off the ironing board or the sewing machine table… forget the “shrinking” stuff… that is not my issue. Not an issue w/metal plates but since the metal quality being used today seems to be questionable (discoloration & etc.), I want to go to glass or ceramic. Am I the only person this is happening to?? Has no one else had this problem or do they know the “trick to make it stick”? I am so frustrated!! Please, can you help?
Try using 2 tablespoons less of the shortening! I think this will solve your problem.
Failproof Recipe that works every time. I have used this recipe for a few years with great success!
Thanks Amber! Glad you love this pie crust as much as we do!
xo
Si
I have tried soooo many pie crust recipes, but have never found one that holds its shape during a blind bake. This is the first one that is truly failproof! It was very easy, tasted delicious, and looked as perfect coming out of the oven as it did going in. Thank you for sharing!
I’m so glad you found it helpful, Kimmi! Thanks for sharing and for reading ABK,
xo
Si
Making pie crust always intimidated me until I found this recipe. Only 3 ingredients and with the step by step pictures with tips, it made the process easy and yummy. I usually make this crust when I’m making apple pie but I’ve also made it when making a cream pie. Just be sure to follow the tips because the first time I made single blind bake crust I made it the same way I made the filled pie crust and my crust shrunk some. After following the tips, I haven’t had anymore problems.
I’m so glad to hear that, Rachael! And the tips are what really make this pie crust turn out really well. Thanks for sharing,
xo
Si
I finally made a successful pie crust! Thank you so much for this recipe—I had almost given up on making homemade pie crust. The dough was so easy to work with and tasted so good with the butter flavored Crisco.
I’m so glad to hear that, Sara! Pie crusts can be difficult but my goal was to make this method easy and fool-proof. Thanks for sharing and for reading ABK,
xo
Si
This recipe is so yummy! The crust is easy to make! It rolls out nicely and makes the most moist, flakey crust! We used to use a food processor which I believe makes it more tough compared to the way this one is done! It’s truly so good if you make sure not to work the dough too much and follow the recipe!
I agree, Noel, one of the biggest mistakes I see is over-working the dough, especially if you use a food processor. Thanks so much for sharing!
xo
Si
I used this recipe using my food processor and it turned out perfect! Best pie crust I’ve ever made. Super easy and the dough was easy to work with. It’ll be my go to recipe from now on!!
I have to say I have worked with MANY different pie crust recipes over the years and this is officially my go to crust!! It was so beautiful to put together, soft and felt lighter than most. The trick is to just be gentle don’t be in a hurry, I used this for my pumpkin pie that I make during the holidays and I added maple syrup to my egg wash and it added something extra that was amazing to it! I highly recommend this!
This is the easiest pie crust recipe I have ever used. Before this pie crust I avoided pies that needed a top because they always fell apart on me when trying to transfer from rolling out to getting in the dish or on top. However, last Thanksgiving several pies looked so good I wanted to try them. When I followed the instructions, it worked beautifully!! Truly, try making pie crust again if it has always been a disaster before. It works! Oh, and the taste! It is a great tasting, beautifully flaky, pie crust. (Now I just need to work on my fluting) Thank you Si!!
Cherylann,
Thank you for sharing this review! So glad you loved this recipe and had success this time!
XO
Si
Can this recipe be doubled?
HI Lissa,
Yes, I double this without any issues!
Si
When you are blind baking a single crust, do you use pie weights?
Hi Annie,
I do not use pie weights. With this method for blind baking, you only need to pierce the sides and bottom of the pastry and bake at a high temperature as directed. Hope this helps!
XO
Si
I have been making this pie crust for years with 100% success. Here are some of my go-to pie tips I have learned over the years. Always use a glass pie pan. Don’t over handle the dough, you want a light and flakey crust. I follow Si’s advice and always let my oven get HOT for 30 minutes before baking the crust. I fill up my 4 cup pyrex glass measuring cup with ice and cold water. Then from there, I measure out the amount of water I need for this recipe, usually just the 1/2 cup. That way I know it is *very* cold so it helps the shortening stay cold and not melt. I love making cream pies and Si’s raspberry pie with this pie crust. If you haven’t tried the raspberry pie, it is life changing!
Thank you so much Annie! I love the tips! The raspberry pie is a favorite of ours too. Happy baking <3
XO
Si
Have you ever tried using Cup for Cup gluten-free flour to make it gluten free?
(Also, there are some pretty solid spam posts at the bottom of this comment thread!)
Hi Laura!
I have used Cup for Cup in my gluten-free sugar cookies and was amazed at the results! It is a great product. Please comment if you have good results with this pie crust, I’m sure our readers would like to know. Thank you for reading ABK!
xo,
Si
ps. thanks for the “heads up’ about the spam posts!
Is it okay to blind bake the pie crusts when baking them ahead of time and use it for the simple pecan pie recipe? Or does the pie crust need to be unbaked?
I’ve made this crust twice, once with top and bottom and one blind bake (I followed your cooking directions for the latter), and both tasted amazing! I am a complete newbie to crusts but I followed all the tips and it was simple. I’m still practicing how to shape and roll but definitely a 5 star recipe!
Thanks for the great tips on the pie crust! I wish I could watch a video of you making the edges of the crust with your fingers or knuckles. I need to see how it is done! 🙂
Also, the pie pictured here looks so delicious! Is it raspberry? Is the recipe posted on that one?
Thanks!
I had given up on making my own pie crusts and had resorted to store bought frozen pie crusts. Last November I watched your demo and gave it try. There is NO COMPARISON, and my family was loving the pies! My son in law gave the ultimate compliment when he said it was the best apple pie he had ever tasted! The idea of making them ahead of time and freezing is brilliant and fun for the grand kids to roll out.
Bless you Si for helping me have the confidence to try again.
Ever since I found this recipe some 8 years ago I have never turned back! It is truly foolproof and I can even get it in the pie dish without mishaps. It creates a beautiful crust and paired with the apple pie or the cranberry apple pie, you have some delicious deserts and basically the only pies I make now.
Thanks so much Elly!
XO
Si
This recipes, easy and great a definite no fail pie crust recipe!!
First time making any of your recipes and of course I had to start with a pie! The crust is made and in the fridge as we speak. Strawberry filling to follow. For some reason pies have always given me trouble but this went together….. so far…. Extremely easy! Excited to see how it turns out!! Thank you!!
Ps. I LOVE your cookbook! It’s absolutely beautiful! Congratulations!! ❤️
Hey Betsy! Thank you for your positive review. I am glad you could put the pie together with ease and that you enjoy the cookbook. How did the pie turn out for you?? Thanks for reading ABK!
XO
Si
This is the best pie crust recipe I have ever used. It has never failed me. I first found it on Pinterest when I made your recipe for Toll House pie. I never wrote it down because it was always there. Imagine my horror when I discovered the crust recipe had been changed! I scoured your website and found it again. Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!
Alex, I am glad you were able to find the recipe again! Thanks for reading ABK and for your positive review!
XO
Si
This recipe changed my life. Seriously. I have struggled to make pie crust for the last 18 years for my pie loving husband. I tried SO MANY recipes, but they all failed. They’d shrink or fall or were not yummy or were not flaky. I tried this recipe 3 years ago and will never try another crust recipe again. I no longer dread making his favorite dessert! Thank you!
Thank you for all the pictures and step by step guide! I taught myself how to make pie from your post and using this crust as a base I have made lots of delicious pies and it has been do much fun! Pie is my husband’s love language so he thanks you, too!
Pie crust is intimidating, but this recipe and your recent tutorials have helped me overcome my doubts. I also love the ABK pie mat and scraper.
I love this recipe! It really is the perfect (and no my complicated) pie crust. Thank you!
This pie crust recipe is excellent. The step by step instructions make it a no fail for making pies. I like it best with butter crisco and regular crisco.
By far my favorite pie recipe! It’s perfect everytime. Use the shortening. Skip the butter.
This pie crust is amazing! Super flaky! Easy to make! Used this for multiple pies so far and they have all turned out so good. So many compliments!
I make pie often because I prefer it over cake. I use this recipe every time I make a pie. The steps are easy to follow and it has never failed me. I have even used this recipe when making chicken pot pie. YUM!